Top Questions Asked By Bread-Winners In Divorce


Everyone who is married at some point thinks about divorce. The longer the marriage, the more at stake: children, property, debts, and a lifetime of joy and sorrow.

Here is my run-down of the four most common questions that I hear from primary income earners when facing or contemplating divorce:

1. Adultery and other grounds for divorce. She’s been sleeping with her tennis coach for the last year – doesn’t that matter? (or, uh, you’ve been sleeping with your tennis coach, does that matter?)  Legally speaking, the simple answer is: No.

Overall, the wrongs committed during the marriage are not something that the courts want to hear about (unless those wrongs pertain to custody issues). And, for the most part, that means that her tango with the tennis instructor – as emotionally devastating as that might be – isn’t going to change the division of assets.

2. Alimony. If she and the tennis guru are shacking up together will that hurt her claim for Alimony (called “maintenance” in New York)? Short answer: Yes, most likely! Many courts are reluctant to award much alimony when the spouse seeking it is living with someone else – particularly if that tennis coach is paying her living expenses.

Alimony is aimed at helping equalize the situation where one spouse’s income is much greater than the other, particularly where she stayed at home and sacrificed a career (or needs training to get back into the job force): the longer the marriage, the longer the support. But, courts, for the most part, seem to be moving away from the idea of life-time alimony.  And, when she may be getting support from a new romantic partner, many courts find that means alimony should end.

Some of the best advice that I ever heard given to the non-income earning spouse: getting a job will empower you to make your own decisions. And income-earners, this means you should encourage your spouse to work so they will be less reliant on you in the long-run.

3. Child Support. Wait, you said if she’s living with Sven, her Swedish tennis coach, I don’t have to pay, right? No. I said you don’t have to pay her – your kids are another matter.

My take-away from most child support schemes (which vary from state-to-state) is that the children are the focus of the court’s concern. Perhaps you feel like you are paying too much and the “child doesn’t need” that level of support. But the additional money might get your ex-spouse a better apartment, which in turn gets your kid into a better apartment and perhaps a better school district. These issues are tied together. But, even if you have shared time, you might get stuck paying child support to your ex-spouse. Maybe that feels unfair, or maybe it needs to be accompanied by a new way of thinking about spending for the child.

4. Pensions. Your employer and you have been setting aside money for your retirement from the job. But that is basically a form of marital income. Think about it: if one spouse is staying at home full-time, how could that spouse be setting aside anything for retirement? Doing your laundry, tending to your dry-cleaning, preparing your meals, doing food shopping and cleaning, and taking care of the kids helps the income-earner but doesn’t allow for a pension. These are all time-consuming tasks that you would have to handle alone – and trust me, they interfere with your ability to work long-hours.

In New York, the law provides each spouse with half the marital portion of the pension (from the date of the marriage to the date of the Summons for Divorce, or another agreed upon date – like the date you sign a separation agreement). If you started working before the marriage, those years are yours. But, in all honesty, pension division is so complicated that most of us need forensic accountants to help with the process. So, on top of sharing your pension, be prepared to pay an expert to help value and divide those assets.

Have a question for the Divorce Artist? Post in the comments or contact me directly


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s