Five Ways That Divorce Mediation Can Help Resolve The “Get” Crisis

Photo credit to Drive By Planet (dot) com

Leah was still chained to her ex-husband: two years after the civil court granted her a divorce, her ex-husband Dovid, a devote orthodox Jew, still refused to give her a religious divorce called a “get.” Without the religious divorce, Leah would not be able to remarry – or even date – in her community. Her life was on hold, tied to her ex- at his whim. And she is not alone.

The number of Jewish women being denied a religious divorce is on the rise. The results are devastating: younger women with children and little money are forced to forgo financial payments or even custody in exchange for a get. Out of desperation, people start taking matters into their own hands. Recently several rabbis were arrested in a plot to beat reluctant husbands into giving gets. This so-called “Get Crisis,” is the product of a myriad of factors, which may be avoided by using divorce mediation.

Here are five ways that divorce mediation can help resolve the get crisis:  

  1. Avoid Court Drama. Taking an Orthodox Jewish man to divorce court may only fuel the feeling that he is being wronged, after all, his religion and community have tasked him as the sole determinate in giving a divorce. Damaged pride and a sense of shame can turn into an angry hurt making him more reluctant to give the get. Instead, divorce mediation avoids the courtroom drama. Mediation is aimed at reaching a low-conflict agreement and fostering a safe space for the couple to work out their issues.
  2. Opt for Creative Solutions. Most people don’t realize that court is limiting: decisions on dividing property and raising your children are made by strangers. Laws are set without your specific case in mind, and definitely without considering your religion. Mediation allows you a world of creative options to craft solutions to the details of your life. The more options available, the more likely the couple can find an agreement that works for them, hopefully lessening the urge to withhold a get.
  3. Level the Playing Field. Many times the refusal to give a get is used as a means of leverage in a custody or financial dispute. However, more often than not, the husband withholds the get as a simple form of control and power over his wife. This is a form of abuse. Because the get creates an automatic power imbalance, mediation can help to rectify the imbalance by creating a safe space for both voices to be heard and giving the couple a forum where they are encouraged to hear one another.
  4. Avoid Public Shame. In Leah’s case, she turned to the Jewish rabbinical courts, which use the power of communal shaming to pressure stubborn husbands. That process alerts the whole community to the problem: contacting local synagogues, local schools, and embarrassingly enough, for Leah, she even sent out letters to everyone invited to her wedding begging them to pressure Dovid and his family. But public shaming can backfire: publicly backing down from his position became even less of an option for Dovid. To give a get would be even more of a blow to his male pride because of the publicity.
  5. Decrease Double Trouble. Asking for a divorce is hard; asking for a divorce and a get makes a tough situation even more difficult.  The media attention to the get crisis and the numerous women who have been waiting for months, years and even decades, highlight the fact that women in the Jewish community need more resources to find a solution to this crisis. Mediation offers an alternative setting from the high-tension court system and rabbinical courts. Divorce mediation, which is still emerging in main stream culture, may help those couples in secular communities find a better way to resolve their divorce.

What are the other ways that mediation can help the Get Crisis? Discuss your ideas or experiences in the comments.

***

This blog was co-authored by Rachel Goldenberg, an associate attorney at the Queens-based divorce firm Richardson Legal PLLC. Ms. Goldenberg has presented “Happily Ever After…or Not: The ‘Get’ As a Form of Domestic Abuse in the Jewish Home and How Mediation Could Be The Answer.” She previously worked in Hofstra’s Mediation Clinic, and also handled court-mandated mediation in Nassau Family Court.

13 thoughts on “Five Ways That Divorce Mediation Can Help Resolve The “Get” Crisis

  1. Great info on a really interesting topic that is probably not often discussed. I think the issues related to how intimate partner violence is perpetrated using religious practice that is explicitly not egalitarian is really fascinating and I bet this information would be really helpful to women in any religion/culture that is designed to impose control. I hope this article helps disseminate this information within insular communities such as these!

    Also, I would be really curious about the factors that have led to the increase in the numbers of women being denied gets. Is it partly because more women are asking as time goes on so more are being denied? Are there other reasons leading to this issue?

    Like

    1. Our thought is that it may be a factor that an increase in the divorce rate (generally and among Orthodox Jews) is a reason for an increase in the “get” crisis. But, withholding a “get” has become a trend among religious Jews. It’s a tough question and requires a lot more statistical research that groups like the Mellman Project and other organizations are working to research and understand.

      Like

  2. Great info on a really interesting topic that is probably not often discussed. I think the issues related to how intimate partner violence is perpetrated using religious practice that is explicitly not egalitarian is really fascinating and I bet this information would be really helpful to women in any religion/culture that is designed to impose control. I hope this article helps disseminate this information within insular communities such as these!

    Also, I would be really curious about the factors that have led to the increase in the numbers of women being denied gets. Is it partly because more women are asking as time goes on so more are being denied? Are there other reasons leading to this issue?

    Like

  3. Excellent post. In all the talk about the Get crisis, I have never once seen “mediation” mentioned as a viable solution.

    I wonder: how to advertise mediation as a viable solution in the ultra-Orthodox community? How to make the process of (secular) mediation more palatable to the ultra-Orthodox population? Is there a way to work with rabbis — not the court, per se, but with trusted religious authority figures — to make this model workable for the average ultra-Orthodox family?

    Like

    1. Thanks Adi!

      Mediation is well on its way as a significant option for secular couples going through a divorce; that usually means that it’s only a matter of time for the religiously inclined to pick up on its benefits. I think spreading the word on the benefits of mediation in both the legal and ultra-Orthodox realms is really the only way to introduce mediation as an option (perhaps the legal community would have to pick up on it first). And of course, not to sound too self promoting, but I think sharing articles like this one can definitely help spread the importance of mediation as an option for ultra-Orthodox couples!

      Like

  4. Very interesting and well written! So sad that this happens. Mediation sounds like a hopeful option to remedy this. I know non-religious people who are happily separated and/or divorced via mediation. I hope the religious crowd takes note and tries it!

    Like

  5. I think this is among the most impߋrtant info for me.

    And i am glad readinɡ your article. Βut should
    rеmark on few general things, Thе web site style is ideal, the articles is really great
    D. Good job, cheers

    Like

  6. Pingback: Gregory Smith

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s