I’ve seen it in my practice a million times — a spouse comes up with a million reasons why their ex- is a horrible person, shouldn’t see the kids and should be in jail. But in the end, the kids are hurt by lack of access to both parents, both parties suffer in a torrid, expensive court case, and the “victim” comes off as a drama queen to friends, family and their employer.
The real culprit: Divorce guilt.
All of your reasons for getting divorced are completely subjective, but totally valid. In New York, as in all states, you can file for divorce under “No Fault” grounds by showing that the marriage has “irretrievably broken-down.” This means all the dirty laundry accumulated during the marriage should not need to be presented to the Court in order to meet grounds requirements. (And grounds are the reasons why you are getting divorced.)
But what do you tell your friends? And how do you respond when your coworkers or your mother says “not to throw a good man away” or “she’s not so bad, try more counseling.”
Many people already feel a lingering sense of guilt and doubt during the divorce – even the ones who initiated the divorce. But sometimes, rather than deal with those feelings in a healthy productive way (like personal therapy, meditation, exercise or chocolate), they start recasting the marriage in an ugly way. This nasty portrait helps justify the divorce, so that when they explain “why” the marriage failed, they feel better about it – because it wasn’t their fault.
This behavior turns the divorce towards extreme conflict: every argument was “verbal abuse”; that beer after work was “alcoholism”; missing Junior’s monthly piano recital was “total disinterest in the children”; and that time your ex- accidentally bumped into you is now “assault.” You start to feel that this domestic strife needs to be documented in the Court to be valid. What does this contested scene look like? In my office, we call it the Two-Step:
Step One: Get an order of protection based on trumped up or exaggerated facts (or in some cases complete lies).
Family Court temporary orders of protection are ex parte that means that the Court only hears from one party and will issue an immediate temporary order based on the facts portrayed by that person. These types of orders are extremely important and needed in domestic violence cases where there is violence going on in the home.
But these orders are also abused by spouses looking for an advantage in a nasty divorce. A “full stay away” order will result in ejecting one spouse from the home. Even a limited (“refrain from”) order is dangerous because the alleged violation of such an order can lead to immediate arrest. Little proof is needed for such an order. I had one attorney, whom I thought of as a mentor, tell me that if my client’s wife was going to lie to get an order of protection, I should tell my client to “break a vase over his own head and claim she did it” so that he could get his own order. (Suffice to say, that attorney is no longer on my mentor list).
Step Two: Up the ante and leverage the possibility of jail for violating the order so that you can get a better deal (more support, more property, and of course custody) – because who wouldn’t trade it all to get rid of criminal charges?
It takes patience and determination to get to the point where I can show the Court the truth: the underlying motives and inconsistent evidence are exposed. But the emotional toll is high. Worse, in cases where there are children, what was already a difficult communication problem between mom and dad has now turned into a train wreck.
Maybe one spouse didn’t listen that the marriage was in trouble until it was too late. Maybe one spouse is a stubborn jerk. But being a jerk is not grounds to warrant an order of protection. If you feel like your guilt is getting in the way of having a lower conflict divorce, explore those feelings with a therapist and try to get over it in a positive way.
The Divorce Artist™️ 
In the beginning of a relationship, we put our new partners on a pedastal and see them as all good. At the end of the relationship, we paint them as all bad. The truth is always somewhere between, even with my ex, who has a warrant for felony bigamy! Seeing him as a complex, three dimensional man again helped me start to find forgiveness and move on.
LikeLike
As an abuse survivor whose husband escalated when I attempted to divorce him I am really upset that there are so many articles claiming that protective orders are only obtained to gain an advantage in a divorce. And by escalated I mean he went from insane frightening rages to pointing a gun at me. Look up the stats on female homicide and tell me this is “usually” a tactic, it’s not. It is a FACT that the most dangerous time for a victim of abuse is when a woman (or man) tries to leave the abuser. I experienced it.
This constant drumbeat about fraudulent protective orders is used by abusers to get rid of NEEDED protective orders. Another issue is that every one of these type articles stresses that a temporary order requires no proof. That is true, but, it’s only for a couple of weeks before you have to go to a hearing where the respondent has a say and representation. And it was NOT easy to get my protective order extended, at that point you have to prove the abuse.
Your assertion that someone could report their abuser with a violation and use it as a bargaining chip for a settlement is false. Once you report a violation, it is the county or state that is prosecuting the offender and you cannot drop the charges. You also might consider that abusers are incredibly manipulative, they rarely show their violence to anyone but their spouse and/or children, to everyone else they often appear upstanding. They can fool you too.
LikeLike
I understand why you are sensitive to this type of article, given your history. I’m happy that you were assertive enough to get out.
That said, fortunately, there are far more divorces in this country that do not involve domestic violence. The divorce rate is at 50%. This article is not aimed at cases involving domestic violence. It has a much more narrow purpose. There is plenty of room to address the abuses of the system without denigrating the plight of domestic violence victims.
If you read closely, I do address that Family Court orders of protection are needed in cases of domestic violence.
In New York the Family Court TOPs can be dropped by the petitioner. A criminal order would be pursued as a function of the DA’s office — but not a Family Court Order. Therefore, you can use a violation of a Family Court Order threat as a possible bargaining chip. An actual violation resulting in criminal action is definitely in the scope of the DA’s office, but it is sometimes very difficult for the DA if the “victim” is no longer participating and the underlying order is dropped.
Best of luck to you. I hope you continue to raise your voice and share your story with others so that they can benefit.
LikeLike
Hi, just wanted to mention, I loved this article.
It was funny! Keep on posting!
LikeLike
Spot on with this write-up, I honestly believe that this amazing site
needs a great deal more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the info!
LikeLike
Hi! I’ve been reading your site for some time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you
a shout out from Humble Tx! Just wanted to mention keep up the great job!
LikeLike
magnificent issues altogether, you just won a new reader.
LikeLike
This is really interesting, You’re a very skilled
blogger. I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of
your excellent post. Also, I’ve shared your website in
my social networks!
LikeLike
Thanks!
LikeLike
Howdy I am so grateful I found your website, I really found you by mistake, while
I was searching on Google for something else, Nonetheless I am here now and would just
like to say thank you for a tremendous post and a all round entertaining blog (I
also love the theme/design), Please do keep up
the great work.
LikeLike
Hello there! I simply wish to offer you a big thumbs up for your excellent information you have got right here on this post.
I am returning to your site for more soon.
LikeLike
Hi there, just wanted to tell you, I loved this blog post.
It was helpful. Keep on posting!
LikeLike